written and directed by Michael Mann
starring: James Caan, Tuesday Weld, James Belushi, Robert Prosky, and Willie Nelson
Michael Mann's (Heat, The Keep, and Manhunter) first directorial effort features James Caan (The Gambler, Hide In Plain Sight, and The Killer Elite) as Frank, a professional thief, and the quintessential anti-hero in this neo film noir.
Loosely adapted from the non-fiction book, “The Home Invaders”, by Frank Hohimer, written in 1975 while he was serving a prison term for his past exploits, Thief chronicles Frank's efforts to create his ultimate "life" - complete with the picture-perfect wife, the picture-perfect child, and the picture-perfect home.
But to accomplish this, Frank must do what he does best -- put down scores. Big scores. Scores that will net him and his partner; Barry, played by Jim Belushi (Gang Related, Red Heat, and Salvador), hundreds of thousands of dollars a night. His specialty is breaking into safes, stealing diamonds and cash - no furs, no coin collections, no stock certificates, no treasury bonds, no cartage, and definitely no "cowboy shit" or "home invasions".
And for a while, everything is going according to Hoyles -- Frank owns a used car lot and a bar, wears $800 suits and a perfect, D-flawless, three-carat diamond ring, and drives a brand new Cadillac every month, -- that is until one of Frank's fences, Joe Gags, is whacked by a local Chicago mobster named Attaglia.
Frank confronts Attaglia and informs him that Joe Gags was holding his money ($180,000) when he went out a twelve-story window. But Attaglia could care less -- until Frank pulls out his .45 automatic, sticks it in his face, and tells him: "I am the last guy in the world that you want to fuck with!"
No truer words were spoken. This was the mob's first mistake. And had the mob guys heeded his warning, this would have been a very short film.
Needless to say, Attaglia and his boss, Leo, played by Robert Prosky (The Keep, The Lords of Discipline, and Things Change) return Frank's money and offer him a job. Reluctant at first, Frank realizes that this is an opportunity to fulfill his dreams on a much tighter timetable.
So Frank, who has always been a loner, agrees to work for Leo, who will set up the scores and fence the merchandise afterwards. Frank's end will be proportionally smaller, but the scores will be bigger and he will have no overhead. Plus, he knows exactly what his cut will be beforehand.
Meanwhile, Frank is busy courting Jessie, a hostess at a local coffee shop, played by Tuesday Weld (Play It As It Lays, Pretty Poison, and Who'll Stop The Rain) in an effort to complete his "life", and is busy trying to get his mentor/surrogate father, "Okla", played by Willie Nelson (Barbarosa, Honeysuckle Rose, and The Red-Headed Stranger) out of prison. Okla has a heart disease, and is afraid that he will die in prison before his parole comes through.
Frank ultimately marries Jessie, buys a brand new house in an upper-class neighborhood in suburban Chicago, adopts a child, and secures Okla's early parole, only to have Okla die before he is released.
In the meantime, Chicago's finest, members of the police department's S.C.U. (Special Crimes Unit) pinch Frank and demand ten percent of his action. But Frank is a stand-up guy and takes his beating and walks out of the precinct. And while he prepares for his first score for Leo, the cops hound him day and night, hoping to catch him in the act and give them a reason to whack him. Frank successfully outsmarts them and heads out to Los Angeles with Barry to do their first score for Leo and the biggest score of their lives.
Upon their return from a well-deserved vacation after the success of the L.A. job, Frank arrives at Leo's house for what he is counting on as a big payday, but he soon discovers that he has been double-crossed. When confronted, Leo threatens Frank's life and everyone he knows and loves. This was the mob's second mistake.
Frank reverts back to the man he was in prison. A man who doesn't care about himself or anyone else. This is the mental attitude he needs to survive and he is willing to die in the process.
After sending Jessie and David away, he burns down his used car lot and blows up his new house, as well as, his bar, and heads back over to Leo's house for a final showdown.
So much for honor among thieves.
While Tuesday Weld's character, Jessie, serves little function above and beyond being an outlet for Frank's expositional recounting of his early years in prison, Willie Nelson, delivers a small, yet bravura, performance, especially in the scene where Frank asks Okla for advice regarding his courtship of Jessie -- "Lie to no one", he says, "If they're somebody close to you, you are going to ruin it with a lie. And if they are a stranger, who the fuck are they that you got to lie to?" What better advice can a father give a son?
Michael Mann, who won kudos for his last film; Heat, was virtually ignored when this (pre-Miami Vice and pre-Crime Story) film was released. In addition to the spectacular performances by all of the above-mentioned actors, Thief is exquisitely photographed by Donald Thorin (Against All Odds, Midnight Run, and Scent of a Woman) and has a riveting sound track by Tangerine Dream (The Keep, Near Dark, and Sorcerer).
And, if you look real closely, you will see Dennis Farina (Get Shorty, Midnight Run, and Out Of Sight) and William L. Petersen (Amazing Grace and Chuck, Manhunter, and To Live and Die in L.A.) in their first screen roles.
[originally published in VMag - September 1998]